One of the lifesaving skills of which Civil Air Patrol is capable is the
airdrop of small objects to survivors or ground teams. The U.S. Coast
Guard makes regular practice of this skill, but we are only allowed to do so
when necessary to save a life. Specifically, paragraph 2-4(g) of CAPR
60-1, CAP Flight Management, says "Prohibited uses of CAP aircraft. The
following uses of CAP aircraft are prohibited ... Dropping of objects unless
such action is to prevent loss of life."
CAP was not always prohibited from air dropping for practice. On the
contrary, message drop competitions were held for CAP members in the 1950s.
While a specific instance could not be located, such activities are
usually prohibited following an incident or accident. A likely conclusion
would be that CAP prohibited dropping items following such an occurrence.
CAPR 60-1 is, of course, more restrictive than the Federal Aviation
Regulations (FARs), which allow for the dropping of objects. Specifically,
Part §91.15 of the FARs states, "No pilot in command of a civil aircraft may
allow any object to be dropped from that aircraft in flight that creates a
hazard to persons or property. However, this section does not prohibit the
dropping of any object if reasonable precautions are taken to avoid injury
or damage to persons or property." In addition to that, one MIGHT be able
to invoke the power of FAR §91.3(b), "In an in-flight emergency requiring
immediate action, the pilot in command may deviate from any rule of this
part to the extent required to meet that emergency." A lawyer, however,
would interpret this regulation narrowly so as not to include an emergency
on the ground as an in-flight emergency. USAF regulations, on the other
hand, allow for appropriate deviations in order to save lives, regardless of
whether those in danger are flying or on the ground, but they only apply to
USAF aircraft. If the requirements of FAR §91.15 are not followed, an
aircraft commander might also be concerned with the fact that he is also
violating FAR §91.13, careless or reckless operation.
Getting down to actual business, how does one go about dropping an
object? In collegiate competitions held around the country every year, the
National Intercollegiate Flying Association, or NIFA, holds a "message drop"
event in addition to other precision flying and academic nonflying events.
Aircrews work in teams of two in order to drop a message container on a
series of two targets. The targets, often 55-gallon drums, will be placed
at the approach and departure end of a runway. Crews must then make a
single pass for two drops upon the targets, flying in cruise configuration.
This competition has distinct advantages and disadvantages over what we
might encounter in the field for CAP. Advantage: competitors drop over a
runway that is obstacle-free, allowing them to descend as low as 200' AGL
(as set by competition rules). Rescue aircraft would need to drop from
500' AGL in order to satisfy FAR §91.119, which requires a safe altitude and
500' from any person, vessel, vehicle, or structure. Disadvantage:
competitors need to drop in cruise configuration. Disadvantage:
competitors need to drop on two targets, we'll have just one.
In actually performing a drop, the team concept is critical. The pilot
will maneuver the aircraft while the observer will give corrections as
necessary. The aircraft should fly directly over the drop target, offset
to the left or right only slightly to correct for winds. The object will
not be falling very long and is only on a streamer, not a parachute:
therefore, winds are of concern, but not of a large one. The observer can
tell the pilot left or right as appropriate. In order to do this, he or
she will be required to open the aircraft window and stick his or her head
out. This creates considerable wind noise if wearing a headset as the
slipstream will blow right over the microphone. It is recommended to
temporarily remove your headset and communicate by shouting over the wind
and engine noises. Its not ideal, but other solutions require equipment
that is not practical for something you might only have to do on in a
life-or-death situation.
On your approach to target, have the observer hold the container in his
right hand and place his entire arm outside of and trailing the aircraft.
Ensure that the streamer is rolled up around the container, otherwise you
stand a good chance of hitting the streamer on the tailplane after the
object is released.
It is a common misconception that the object, when dropped, will move
considerably forward along the path of the aircraft. After all, that is
what physics teaches us! Practical experience differs in the case of a very
lightweight message container, however. The object will slow down to a
dead fall very quickly. Therefore, you should not release the container
until very nearly directly overhead the target. As a general guide, when
flying a Cessna aircraft, release the object when the target crosses the
landing gear strut of the aircraft.
If you follow this method, your greatest errors will occur in early or
late releases. Your distance to the left or right of centerline will be
minimal--very easily 50 feet or less with just a couple practice drops.
Take this into consideration when determining your run-in axis for drops in
the field. For example, if one were dropping a critically-needed first aid
item to a ground team parked next to a road, consider flying down the road
and dropping. You would also want to make a couple of practice runs at a
higher altitude to look out for obstacles and get a good idea of where the
target is located. This will keep you safe if dropping containers in the
field.
Of course the 'safest' place for anyone on the ground to stand is
directly at your target.
For a parting note, please keep these recommendations: in mind if you
choose to drop objects for practice or for in an emergency situation.
1)Keep the object LIGHT--this way if it inadvertently hits something of
value, it will cause little or no damage. 2) Before the balloon goes up
and you find yourself in a position to need to drop something in an
emergency, PRACTICE few drops with a non-CAP aircraft. Rent something from
an FBO. When you make drop containers, make enough for one flight of
SEVERAL practices. 3) Use radio coordination with personnel on the ground
when it is possible. They can give you corrections for your drops.